** stop press **
On February 13th 2002, the Caistel Tioram inquiry upheld the SPAB in Scotland's
point of view. The SPAB is delighted and hopes that the owner will now take steps
to protect the castle for the enjoyment of future generations.
Surrounded by woods, ruined Castle Tioram stands on a tidal island in Loch Moidart
on the West coast of Scotland. It can be seen from the sea and outlying islands
and approached on foot at low tide.
Until the beginning of the seventeenth century Castle Tioram was a seat of the
Lord of the Isles and one of the administrative and political centres for the
West Highlands and Islands. In the 1715 rebellion, after re-capturing their old
castle from the Hanovarians, the Macdonalds then torched the building rather than
let it fall into enemy hands. And it has stood as a romantic monument to the Jacobite
uprising ever since.
In 1996 the site was put up for sale by its American owners and purchased by
Anta Estates Ltd, acting for an anonymous offshore owner.
Anta Estates lodged a planning application with Highland District Council to
convert the ruin into a private house, which would involve closing off free public
access, building access roads, roofing the ruin, putting in electricity, plumbing
and other modern conveniences, which was granted. However, as the ruin is also
a Scheduled Ancient Monument, alterations to the building require Ancient Monument
Consent, which the Scottish Ministers declared they were minded to refuse.
In 2001 the case went to an unprecedently long Local Public Inquiry, where SPAB
in Scotland, alongside Historic Scotland spoke against restoration and in favour
of loving the building for what it is.